Chapter 4 - What Rebeca KnewBy sunrise, the perfect house no longer looked perfect.

Yellow police tape wrapped around the white gate. Officers walked in and out carrying evidence bags. The pale living room floor had been carved open from wall to wall. Cameras flashed over hidden compartments, narrow tunnels, children’s blankets, food wrappers, medicine bottles, and a small locked door behind the concrete wall.
Neighbors stood outside in clusters, wearing robes, workout clothes, and shocked expressions that did not hide their hunger for details.
Mateo sat in the hospital hallway with his elbows on his knees, his hands bandaged, his shirt covered in dust and his son’s fingerprints.
Laura was inside Emiliano’s room.
Only one parent had been allowed at a time while doctors examined him, and Mateo had stepped out because Emiliano cried whenever a male doctor came too close. That fact alone had nearly made Mateo punch a hole through the hallway wall.
Jimena slept across two plastic chairs with Emiliano’s dinosaur tucked beneath her chin.
For months, Mateo had watched his daughter grow quiet and strange. She stared at corners. She hated closed doors. She refused to walk over certain wooden floors. He and Laura had taken her to therapists, prayed with her, sat beside her bed, bought night-lights and stuffed animals.
All that time, she had not been haunted by imagination.
She had been remembering.
A vending machine hummed at the end of the hallway. Nurses moved softly. Somewhere nearby, a baby cried.
Mateo looked at his daughter and thought of the question no father should ever have to ask.
How many times had Jimena tried to tell him the truth in a language he refused to understand?
Detective Duarte appeared at the end of the hall holding two paper cups of coffee.
Mateo stood immediately. “What did Santiago say?”
Duarte handed him one cup. “Nothing useful.”
“Where is he?”
“In custody.”
“And Rebeca?”
“In custody too.”
Mateo laughed once, bitterly. “Good. Now make them talk.”
Duarte leaned against the wall. He looked like a man who had not slept in years. “Your sister is asking for you.”
Mateo’s face hardened. “No.”
“She says she’ll only speak to you.”
“Then she can rot quietly.”
Duarte nodded as if he had expected that answer. “I understand.”
“No, you don’t.”
“You’re right,” Duarte said. “I don’t. But there may be more children.”
The hallway seemed to shrink.
Mateo looked toward Emiliano’s room. “More?”
“We don’t know. We found evidence that the hidden space was not built only for your son and Tomás Aguilar. There are marks on the wall. Initials. Dates. Some older than your son’s disappearance.”
Mateo’s stomach turned. “What kind of house is this?”
Duarte’s eyes darkened. “That is what we need to find out.”
Mateo pressed the coffee cup between both hands until the lid bent.
Rebeca had worn pearl earrings to Emiliano’s birthday. She had brought Jimena a pink coat last Christmas. She had sat next to Laura at church memorial services, head bowed, handkerchief pressed to her eyes.
All that time.
All that time, Emiliano had been breathing beneath her life.
“Did she hurt him?” Mateo asked.
Duarte did not answer quickly enough.
Mateo stepped closer. “Did she?”
“We know he was drugged at least sometimes. Doctors are running tests. We found sedatives in the house.”
Mateo closed his eyes.
Duarte continued carefully. “Emiliano told one nurse that his aunt gave him ‘sleeping juice’ when visitors came.”
Mateo turned away.
He did not cry. Not then.
Something inside him went too still for tears.
Duarte lowered his voice. “There’s something else.”
Mateo looked back.
“The house plans on file do not match the structure. The hidden rooms were added during renovation, but permits show only flooring, electrical, and cosmetic work. Santiago Varela signed off as consultant.”
“Santiago built the prison.”
“That’s our working theory.”
“And Rebeca?”
Duarte studied him. “That depends on what she says now.”
Mateo stared down the hallway toward the elevators.
Every cell in his body rejected the idea of sitting across from his sister. But if there was even one more child, one more family living the nightmare that had hollowed out his home, then Mateo had no right to protect himself from pain.
He looked at Jimena sleeping in the chair.
“She doesn’t see Rebeca,” he said.
“Of course not.”
“And Laura doesn’t know until I come back.”
Duarte nodded.
Twenty minutes later, Mateo walked into a small interview room at the police station.
Rebeca sat on the other side of a metal table, handcuffed, hair undone, face bare of makeup. Without the white furniture, the soft lighting, the elegant clothes, she looked smaller. Older. But not innocent.
Mateo sat across from her.
For a long moment, neither spoke.
Then Rebeca whispered, “Is he alive?”
Mateo’s hand slammed onto the table so hard she flinched.
“You do not get to ask that like you care.”
Her eyes filled. “I do care.”
“You buried him under your house.”
“I hid him.”
“As if that’s better?”
“I saved him from Santiago.”
Mateo leaned back slowly.
There it was.
The first rope of the story she would try to climb.
“Start talking,” he said.
Rebeca swallowed. “You remember my apartment after the divorce?”
“I remember Jimena hated it.”
“She heard Tomás.”
Mateo felt cold move through him.
Rebeca looked at the mirrored wall, knowing detectives were watching. “Santiago owned that building. He said he had storage rooms in the basement. Private rooms. I didn’t know at first.”
“At first,” Mateo repeated.
“I was lonely. Broke. Angry. I had lost everything in the divorce. He helped me. He gave me money. He told me I deserved better.”
Mateo said nothing.
“He said some parents didn’t deserve their children.” Her voice shook. “He said some children could have better lives if they were taken away quietly and placed somewhere safe.”
Mateo stared at her in disbelief. “You are describing kidnapping.”
“I know that now.”
“You knew it then.”
Rebeca began crying. “I didn’t know about the rooms. Not until Tomás. I heard him one night. Crying through the wall. Santiago told me the boy had been rescued from abusive parents, that he was waiting for documents.”
“And you believed him?”
“I wanted to.”
Mateo laughed without humor. “That is the first honest thing you’ve said.”
Rebeca wiped her cheek with her shoulder because her hands were cuffed. “Then Emiliano disappeared.”
Mateo stopped moving.
She looked at him. “He saw Santiago at Mamá’s house.”
“At my mother’s house?”
Rebeca nodded. “Santiago came to pick me up. He wasn’t supposed to go inside. Emiliano saw him near the back door. He recognized him from my apartment.”
Mateo’s chest tightened.
“Emiliano told me there was a boy singing in Tía’s wall,” Rebeca whispered. “He asked Santiago if Tomás could come play.”
Mateo’s hands curled into fists.
“Santiago panicked. He grabbed Emiliano and put him in his car. I followed. I screamed at him. I told him to let the boy go.”
“But you didn’t call the police.”
Rebeca sobbed. “He had videos.”
“What videos?”
She looked at the mirror again.
“Videos of me feeding Tomás. Opening the basement door. Talking to him. Looking like I was part of it.”
Mateo stared at her.
“You were part of it.”
“I was afraid.”
“My son was seven.”
Rebeca lowered her head.
Mateo stood. “I’m done.”
“No, wait.” Rebeca leaned forward. “There are files. Santiago keeps records. Names. Payments. Families. I know where they are.”
Mateo froze.
“Where?”
Rebeca whispered an address.
Duarte entered the room so quickly Mateo knew he had been listening from behind the mirror.
Rebeca looked up at her brother one last time.
“I didn’t mean for Emiliano to suffer.”
Mateo leaned over the table until their faces were inches apart.
“Then you should have loved him more than you feared being caught.”
Her face crumpled.
Mateo walked out.
In the hallway, his phone rang.
Laura.
He answered quickly. “What happened?”
For a moment, all he heard was her breathing.
Then she said, “Emiliano is awake.”
May you like
Mateo closed his eyes.
“He wants to tell us what happened the day he disappeared.”
Related Stories