Chapter 4 - THE NURSE WHO SHOULD HAVE BEEN DEADEvelyn Price was not dead.
She was living under the name Marie Benton in a small blue house outside Albany with triple locks, blackout curtains, and a German shepherd trained to attack men in suits.
Nico found her because people who disappear badly leave records.
A hospital pension routed through a shell account. A property bought in cash. A prescription filled under one name and delivered to another.
By midnight, Dante and Arabella were in an SUV heading north through freezing rain.
Arabella sat in the back seat, wearing borrowed clothes that did not fit. Dante’s coat remained around her shoulders. She kept touching the ends of her short hair, as if she could not believe the weight was gone.
“Do I look different?” she asked suddenly.
Dante glanced at her through the dark window reflection.
“Yes.”
“Like her?”
“Who?”
“The girl in the newspapers.”
Dante paused.
“No.”
Her face fell.
“You look like the woman who survived what they did to her.”
She turned away before he could see if that answer hurt or healed.
They reached Albany after two in the morning.
The blue house sat at the end of a dead-end road. The porch light was off. The curtains were drawn. Snow clung to the roof.
Dante stepped out first.
The German shepherd started barking before they reached the porch.
A voice shouted from inside. “I have a gun.”
Dante looked at Arabella.
“Stay behind me.”
But Arabella moved past him.
She stood in the porch light, shivering.
“My name is Arabella Vale.”
The barking stopped.
Inside the house, something fell.
A curtain shifted.
The door opened two inches.
An elderly woman stared out with red-framed glasses and a pistol in her shaking hand.
The moment she saw Arabella’s face, the gun dropped.
“Oh, sweet Jesus,” she whispered.
Arabella’s mouth trembled.
“You remember me?”
Evelyn Price began to cry.
“I never stopped.”
Inside, the house smelled like coffee, dog fur, and fear.
Evelyn made them sit at the kitchen table while she checked every window twice. Her hands shook so badly Dante took the kettle from her before she burned herself.
“I thought you were dead,” Evelyn said, looking at Arabella. “I thought he finally killed you.”
“He told me you were dead.”
“He tried.”
She pulled down the collar of her sweater.
A scar ran across her shoulder.
“He shot me and dumped me in the river. I woke up three days later in a county hospital with no ID. I knew if I went back, he’d finish it.”
Arabella stared at the scar.
“I’m sorry.”
Evelyn reached across the table and gripped her hand.
“No, baby. I am sorry. I should have taken you with me.”
Dante leaned forward.
“Tell us what happened after the yacht.”
Evelyn looked at him. “Your father sent me.”
Dante went still.
“Antonio?”
She nodded. “He knew Malcolm was planning something. He didn’t know exactly what. He paid me to take an overnight shift at the private clinic where Arabella was brought after the explosion.”
Arabella whispered, “Explosion?”
“There was no explosion,” Evelyn said.
The room went silent.
“There was a fire staged offshore. Enough debris to convince investigators. But Arabella wasn’t on the yacht when it burned. She had been drugged and moved before midnight.”
Arabella pressed a hand to her stomach.
“My father?”
“Sterling believed you were on that boat.”
Dante’s voice turned dangerous. “Malcolm let his brother think his daughter was dead.”
“He needed Sterling broken,” Evelyn said. “A grieving man signs papers. Changes trusts. Makes mistakes.”
“What papers?” Dante asked.
Evelyn stood and walked to a pantry.
From behind rows of canned soup, she pulled out a sealed envelope wrapped in plastic.
“I kept copies.”
She placed them on the table.
Inside were medical records, forged death certifications, trust amendments, and one photograph.
Arabella at nineteen, unconscious in a hospital bed.
Malcolm beside her.
His hand rested on her shoulder.
The gold ring was clearly visible.
On the back of the photo, Evelyn had written:
HE SAID SHE WOULD WAKE UP AS NO ONE.
Arabella pushed back from the table and ran to the sink, choking.
Dante followed but did not touch her.
Behind him, Evelyn said, “There’s more.”
Dante turned.
Evelyn’s face had gone pale.
“Malcolm wasn’t working alone.”
“Who else?”
She looked at Arabella with pity.
“Your fiancé.”
Arabella gripped the sink.
A name burst through the darkness in her mind.
May you like
Caleb.
And with it came the memory of a man kissing her forehead before handing her a glass of champagne.
Related Stories
